Compare

Why Mortar? (vs Stardrop)

Stardrop is a Stardew Valley manager; Mortar reads its profiles. Use Mortar to search for mods in-app, have SMAPI installed, or manage more than Stardew.

ComparedMortarStardrop
PlatformsWindows, Linux, Steam DeckWindows, Linux, macOS (v1.10.4)
Games3331, Stardew Valley (docs)
SMAPIInstalled for you; updates offeredMust be installed first; updates offered (docs)
Finding modsBrowse searches Nexus ModsCurseForgeGitHubLocal archives, or Mod Manager Download on Nexus Mods (docs)
SharingA link or a .mortar fileA JSON export (source)
ConflictsContent Patcher conflicts explained in ProblemsDuplicate mods skipped, missing dependencies reported
LicenceAGPL-3.0GPL-3.0

Highlighted: the stronger of the two, or both where they are even.

Where Stardrop is stronger

  • Native macOS builds.
  • Years of tuning for one game: per-profile mod configs and Nexus Collections support (features).

Moving from Stardrop

In Profiles, choose Import… and Mortar lists Stardrop profiles, with a preview. Stardrop and the game's Mods folder are left as they were.